Litigation Filed January 23, 2008 Challenging Drilling in HD Mountains

The complaint is available for download here (pdf).

The San Juan National Forest released its Record of Decision (ROD) for drilling the HD Mountains on April 4, 2007.

The ROD responded to the public’s two most severe concerns about drilling on the Fruitland formation outrcrop and drilling in the roadless area in the following ways. Compare maps of the draft and final preferred alternatives to see changes.

Roadless Area Impacts
The Draft EIS proposed 57 well pads and 38 miles of new roads within the boundaries of the HD Mountains inventoried roadless area. New roads and wells were planned for essentially every ridgeline and every valley.

The Final EIS and ROD significantly reduces the number of authorized wells and roads. It places the heart of the roadless area (Ignacio Creek) off limits to
coalbed methane drilling because of concerns about landslide hazards, slope stability, erosion, and watershed impacts, although this restriction could be lifted at some future date if industry demonstrates an ability to construct roads and well pads without impacts. The FEIS leaves the entire Ignacio Creek watershed undeveloped (good news!), for the time being, and also precludes development across portions of the top of the HD Mountains. The change reduces the impact to the roadless area from 13,000 acres down to 5,000 acres (out of 27,000 acres the USFS considers roadless).

However, there are still several serious concerns about the remaining wells planned for the roadless area. The agency’s preferred alternative includes road construction across 7 miles of steep slopes at high hazard for landslides to reach many of the remaining drilling sites authorized in the roadless area.

• More details at www.savehdmountains.org

watch a 10-minute video on YouTube - "The Drill Man Cometh"

The HD Mountains are one of the last undrilled areas in the San Juan Basin.
The HD Mountains (named for a 19th-century cattle brand) offer the last, best opportunity to preserve the undeveloped foothills of the San Juan Mountains in southwest Colorado. This 40,000-acre roadless area on the San Juan National Forest contains many of the last remaining stands of unlogged, 300-year-old ancient ponderosa pine forests in the Southern Rockies. Ignacio Creek is perhaps the most pristine, low-elevation watershed in the entire San Juans.

The San Juan Basin is one of the most intensively-drilled areas in Colorado and New Mexico, with over 40,000 total wells, 18,000 of which are currently producing. The HD Mountains are one of the last undrilled areas left in the San Juan Basin, and is in the upper right-hand corner of the map.

  • Download the complete map of drilling in the San Juan Basin [pdf]
  • Download maps specific to the proposed HD drilling [pdf]

Fruitland Outcrop Impacts

The preferred alternative proposes to authorize about 40 new coalbed methane wells within 1.5 miles of the Fruitland Formation outcrop, nearly all of which are located in Archuleta County. As is well documented from recent history with drilling near the outcrop in La Plata County, expected consequences include methane seeps that could contaminate homes and water wells and drying up springs and water wells from the groundwater drawdown associated with CBM extraction.

The preferred alternative does not respond to the overwhelming public comment about the serious, irreversible impacts from drilling near the outcrop. Five local governments -- La Plata and Archuleta county commissions, and town councils of Bayfield, Ignacio, and Durango -- unanimously passed resolutions calling for no new wells near the outcrop. The BLM’s Southwest Resource Advisory Council raised similar concerns. Thousands of individual comments made the same point. For more information go to www.savehdmountains.org.

Untitled Document
     
Contact
I want to help; please keep me informed with regular updates, click here.